Tas Cas Bulletin 1/2011
Intro
Click here to view the complete magazine online or download the attachment at the bottom of this page.
Football related case law in this issue:
| Arbitration | Parties | Keywords |
|---|---|---|
| TAS 2009/A/1828 & 1829 | Olympique Lyonnais c. US Soccer Federation (Sonia Bompastor) & US Soccer Federation (Camille Abily) | délivrance d’un Certificat International de Transfert (CIT); jonction de procédures; absence de qualité pour faire appel d’un club à l’encontre d’une décision du Juge Unique de la FIFA relative à la délivrance d’un CIT; qualité pour défendre dans le cadre d’un appel dirigé contre une décision du juge unique de la FIFA |
| CAS 2009/A/1880 & 1881 | FC Sion & E. v. FIFA & Al-Ahly Sporting Club | unilateral termination of an employment contract without just cause; alleged violation of due process rights; standing to appeal; link between the release of an ITC and the related claims for a contractual breach; wrong designation of a party; extent of the liability according to Art. 17 para. 2 of the RSTP; primacy of the liquidated damages provisions; scope of discretion of the adjudicating body when determining the amount of compensation due; principle of the “positive interest”; law of the country concerned; loss of a possible transferfee; Protected Period; specificity of sport; sporting sanction. |
| CAS 2009/A/1881 | E. v. FIFA & Al-Ahly Sporting Club | modification of the motions for relief in the Appeal Brief; cumulative conditions to trigger the lis pendens exception; difference between the concept of “pendency” and that of “jurisdiction”; serious reasons to require the stay of the arbitral proceedings; purpose of Art. 22 RSTP; submission to the jurisdiction of the FIFA; validity of clauses “by reference” to confer jurisdiction to the CAS. |
| CAS 2009/A/1909 | RCD Mallorca SAD & A. v. FIFA & UMM Salal SC | unilateral termination of an employment contract without just cause during the Protected Period; burden of proof; applicable national law; material error; signature of two contracts for the same period; liquidated damages; Protected Period; sporting sanctions |
| TAS 2009/A/1960& 1961 | Trabzonspor c. LOSC Lille Métropole | résiliation unilatérale du contrat de travail sans juste motif; droit applicable: élection de droit indirecte, exclusion de la règle de conflit; autorité de chose jugée; forme du contrat; réserve de forme; rémunération du joueur; valeur des services d’un joueur; période protégée: point de départ de la nouvelle période; période protégée: facteur aggravant pour la fixation de l’indemnité; intérêts |
| CAS 2009/A/1974 | Nicolo Napoli v. S.C.F.C. Universitatea Craiova & RFF | disciplinary sanction of the club on its former coach; legal relationship between the RFF and the RPFL and standing to be sued; duty of the first adjudicating body to inform the parties of their rights to request reasons and file an appeal; right of the CAS Panel to issue a new decision in replacement of the decision appealed against; power of the employer to exercise disciplinary control after the end of the contractual relationship |
| CAS 2010/A/2071 | IFA v. FAI, Daniel Kearns & FIFA | admissibility of new documents submitted after the filing of the Appeal/Answer; principles governing the interpretation of rules; rules governing the eligibility of players to play for the representative teams of national associations; distinction between a “shared” and a “dual” nationality; hierarchy of norms |
| CAS 2010/A/2172 | O. v. UEFA | match fixing; production of new evidence; standard of proof requested in the context of match fixing; violation of the principles of conducts by a referee; disciplinary sanction |
Preview
Table des matières / Table of contents
| Page | Message du Président du CIAS / Message of the ICAS President |
|---|---|
| 1 | Message du Président du CIAS |
| 2 | Message of the ICAS President |
| Page | Articles et commentaires / Articles and commentaries | Author |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | The jurisprudence of the CAS in football matters (except Art. 17 RSTP) | Jean-Phillipe Dubey |
| 13 | Standing to sue, a procedural issue before the CAS | Estelle de La Rochefoucauld |
| 21 | Status of the Player and Training Compensation | Despina Mavromati |
| 31 | Selected issues related to CAS jurisdiction in light of the jurisprudence of the Swiss Supreme Court | Despina Mavromati |
| Page | Jurisprudence majeure / Leading cases | Parties | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| 41 | Arbitration CAS 2007/A/1396 & 1402 | World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) & Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI) v. Alejandro Valverde & Real Federación Española de Ciclismo (RFEC) | 31 May 2010 |
| 58 | Arbitration CAS 2008/A/1545 | Andrea Anderson, LaTasha Colander Clark, Jearl Miles-Clark, Torri Edwards, Chryste Gaines, Monique Hennagan, Passion Richardson v. International Olympic Committee (IOC) | 18 December 2009 |
| 65 | Arbitration CAS 2008/A/1545 | Andrea Anderson, LaTasha Colander Clark, Jearl Miles-Clark, Torri Edwards, Chryste Gaines, Monique Hennagan, Passion Richardson v. International Olympic Committee (IOC) | 16 July 2010 |
| 75 | Arbitrage TAS 2009/A/1828 & 1829 | Olympique Lyonnais c. US Soccer Federation (Sonia Bompastor) & US Soccer Federation (Camille Abily) | 18 mars 2010 |
| 81 | Arbitrage TAS 2009/A/1879 | Alejandro Valverde Belmonte c. Comitato Olimpico Nazionale Italiano (CONI) & Agence Mondiale Antidopage (AMA) & Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI) | 16 mars 2010 |
| 99 | Arbitration CAS 2009/A/1880 & 1881 | FC Sion & E. v. Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) & Al-Ahly Sporting Club | 1 June 2010 |
| 119 | Arbitration CAS 2009/A/1881 | E. v. Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) & Al-Ahly Sporting Club | 7 October 2009 |
| 124 | Arbitration CAS 2009/A/1909 | RCD Mallorca SAD & A. v. FIFA & UMM Salal SC | 25 January 2010 |
| 133 | Arbitration CAS 2009/A/1912 & 1913 | Claudia Pechstein & Deutsche Eisschnelllauf Gemeinschaft e.V. (DESG)v. International Skating Union (ISU) | 25 November 2009 |
| 148 | Arbitrage TAS 2009/A/1960 | Trabzonspor c. LOSC Lille Métropole | 5 mai 2010 |
| 148 | Arbitration TAS 2009/A/1961 | LOSC Lille Métropole c. Trabzonspor & S. | 5 mai 2010 |
| 159 | Arbitration CAS 2009/A/1974 | Nicolo Napoli v. S.C.F.C. Universitatea Craiova & Romanian Football Federation (RFF) | 16 July 2010 |
| 166 | Arbitration CAS 2010/A/2071 | Irish Football Association (IFA) v. Football Association of Ireland (FAI), Daniel Kearns & Fédération Internationale de Football Association (FIFA) | 27 September 2010 |
| 177 | Arbitration CAS 2010A/2119 | International Federation of Body Building and Fitness (IFBB) v.International World Games Association (IWGA) | 19 November 2010 |
| 183 | Arbitration CAS 2010 A/2172 | O. v. Union des Associations Européennes de Football (UEFA) | 18 January 2011 |
| Page | Jugements du Tribunal Fédéral / Judgments of the Federal Tribunal |
|---|---|
| 190 | 4A_284/2009, Judgement of 24 November 2009, First Civil Law Court |
| 196 | 4A_624/2009, Arrêt du 12 avril 2010, Ire Cour de droit civil |
| 200 | 4A_456/2009, Judgment of 3 May 2010, First Civil Law Court |
| 209 | 4A_386/2010, Arrêt du 3 janvier 2011, Ire Cour de droit civil |
| Page | Informations diverses / Miscellaneous |
|---|---|
| 223 | Membres du CIAS 2011-2014/ICAS Members 2011-2014 |
| 224 | ICAS Board/Bureau du CIAS |
| 224 | Publications récentes relatives au TAS/Recent publications related to CAS |